Strengthening Climate Advisory Councils in Chile, Guatemala, and Mexico
This paper discusses the first comparative assessment of three of the longest-established climate councils in Latin America, in Chile, Guatemala and Mexico. Drawing on a review of legal and policy documents and 43 semistructured interviews conducted in 2026 with council members, secretariat staff, government officials, academics and civil soceity actors, the paper examines how each council operates, what shapes its influence and how it fits within national climate governance, closing with recommendations.
Effective climate action depends not only on ambitious targets but on institutions that sustain policy across political cycles. In Latin America, among the world’s most climate-exposed and unequal regions, legislative ambition has often outpaced a state’s capacity to implement it (Buylova et al. 2024; OECD 2025). Climate councils—expert bodies officially mandated to advise governments on climate policy (ICCN 2026)—are one response: They offer evidence-based advice, convene expertise, and lend continuity to decision-making (Dudley et al. 2021). This paper examines the institutional and political conditions that enable or constrain them.
This working paper offers the first comparative assessment of three of the longest-established climate councils in Latin America, which operate with three distinct models:
- In Chile, the Scientific Advisory Committee on Climate Change (Comité Científico Asesor para el Cambio Climático; C4) is a statutory scientific council.
- The Guatemalan System of Climate Change Sciences (Sistema Guatemalteco de Ciencias del Cambio Climático; SGCCC) is an agreement-based science system.
- Mexico has the long-standing Climate Change Council (Consejo de Cambio Climático; C3), composed of experts from the social, private and academic sectors.
These cases were chosen for their contrasting mandates and levels of institutionalization. Drawing on a review of legal and policy documents and 43 semistructured interviews conducted in 2026 with council members, secretariat staff, government officials, academics, and civil society actors, the paper examines how each council operates, what shapes its influence, and how it fits within national climate governance.
The three cases suggest that the influence of climate advisory councils depends not only on the quality of their advice but also on the institutional and political conditions under which they act. Across the cases, interviewees highlighted the importance of factors such as legal foundations, adequate resourcing, sustained engagement with policymakers, and mechanisms that connect scientific advice to implementation and accountability processes. While climate councils can represent a promising institutional innovation for strengthening climate governance, their effectiveness ultimately depends on the conditions that enable them to operate, influence decisionmaking, and sustain their work over time. These lessons may be relevant not only for the councils examined here but also for newer and prospective advisory bodies across Latin America and beyond.
Key Findings
- Across the three countries, stakeholders identified several pathways thorugh which councils shape climate policy and governance processes. These include early-stage technical review of flagship instruments; agenda setting and convening; policy legitimation; and an institutional-memory role amid high government turnover.
- While most climate councils belonging to the International Climate Councils Network (ICCN) are mandated to perform a watchdog or compliance function, none of the three studied here has a comparable mandate, although multiple council interviewees aspired to this role.
- Whether councils fulfill their roles depends on the institutional conditions in which they operate, including clear legislative mandates, freedom from undue political influence, adequate resources and secretariat capacity, respected technical membership, and, critically, an obligation on government to respond to their advice.
- To realize the councils' potential, legislatures, governments, the councils themselves and international partners will need to take action.
- The three cases suggest that the influence of climate advisory councils depends not only on the quality of their advice but also on the institutional and political conditions under which they act.
Projects
Long-Term Climate Strategies
Part of Climate