What It Takes for Climate Councils to Have Influence: Lessons from Chile, Guatemala and Mexico
Climate councils are a promising institutional innovation that can help governments incorporate climate science, accountability and oversight into climate policies.
As countries move from setting climate commitments to implementation, they will need to incorporate climate science, effective oversight and accountability alongside national priorities. Climate advisory councils — bodies of scientists and experts that provide evidence-based advice to inform policymaking in at least 25 countries — are a promising institutional innovation that can support these functions.
Previous studies have shown how climate councils have strengthened climate policy ambition and oversight in other parts of the world. But most studies have focused on comparatively well-resourced councils, primarily in Europe. Councils lacking that level of institutional support face more operational challenges that constrain their influence. Yet they can still be seen as providing value to countries’ climate governance — with potential to do even more.
That is among the main findings of a new working paper by World Resources Institute and Grantham Research Institute at the London School of Economics, which offers the first comparative empirical assessment of these climate councils in Latin America. Our study sheds light on how climate councils in Chile, Guatemala and Mexico are contributing to their countries’ climate governance. It also outlines actions policymakers and partners could take to strengthen their councils’ ability to increase ambition and aid implementation.
Here, drawing on evidence from the three countries we examined, we highlight some of the conditions — including resources and mandates — that enable climate councils to be an even greater tool in meeting the challenges facing climate policy and supporting effective climate governance.
How Do Climate Councils Work and Where Do They Come From?
Climate councils are expert bodies officially mandated — often, though not always, through national law — to advise climate policymakers and line ministries on science-based policy. There are 31 councils from 25 countries that are part of the International Climate Councils Network (ICCN), which provides mutual support and amplifies their work. While there is some variation by country, at their best, climate councils are composed of recognized scientists or sector experts who supply advice on a range of climate policies, convene stakeholders, monitor and sometimes can demand answers on policy ambition or implementation. Because they are not elected officials, councils often work beyond annual national budget and election cycles.
Our study specifically looked at Chile's Scientific Advisory Committee on Climate Change (C4), Mexico's Climate Change Council (C3) and the Guatemalan System of Climate Change Sciences (SGCCC). Chile’s and Mexico’s councils were created directly through framework climate laws in 2024 and 2013, respectively. Guatemala’s council was launched in 2014, a consequence of its own climate law, but lacks statutory protections and requires a renegotiated agreement between its founding institutional members every several years.
There are many ways of setting up climate councils, but despite important differences in their legal foundations and institutional design, the three councils we studied are all intended to provide independent, expert advice to support climate policymaking. People we interviewed for our research generally viewed the councils as technically credible and legitimate sources of scientific and sectoral expertise.
Implementation is a key focus area at this year’s UN Climate Change Conference (COP31), as the second Global Stocktake will pressure governments to show that climate commitments are yielding results. We found that even with limited mandates, no budget and the lack of any obligations for government agencies to respond to their advice, that climate councils in Mexico, Guatemala and Chile demonstrated value in supporting these goals. The councils ensured policy coherence across administrations, directly influencing the content and development of nationally determined contributions (NDCs) and convened subnational stakeholders and affected communities that were left out of policy discussions, to name a few examples.
For instance, the C4 directly influenced the technical content of Chile’s updated NDC (NDC 3.0) while the C3 led the development of a more participatory process that was used to engage affected populations and inform Mexico’s NDC 3.0 and Special Program on Climate Change, which translates commitments to actions.
The SGCCC has played a critical role in preserving institutional memory on climate action across administrations in Guatemala, ensuring policy coherence and engaging subnational, Indigenous and civil society leaders. As one member of the Guatemalan SGCCC told us while researching our study, “the system has served as a repository [across governmental transitions] ... The damage to a country when that institutional memory does not exist is enormous.”
Elsewhere in Latin America, Colombia, Peru and Brazil are implementing laws or creating related bodies, while other governments are designing councils now.
By examining how climate councils are operating in Mexico, Guatemala and Chile, we can understand how countries get the most from their climate councils.
From Volunteers to Institutions
Council members across the three countries were widely viewed by stakeholders we interviewed as committed, competent sectoral experts or scientists who volunteer their time to strengthen their countries’ approach to climate. But technical and administrative resource constraints make it challenging for the councils to provide rigorous analysis, comment on multiple key policy documents on tight timelines and also limit their capacity to convene stakeholders.
Councils in wealthier countries commonly work with stable public funding and secretariats of 10 to 30 people, with some of them compensated for their time. All three councils we studied rely on unpaid members, and none has a dedicated budget. One of our strongest takeaways is that these councils have managed to make immense contributions relative to their resources leading to the question of how much more they could do if staffed and funded at an appropriate level.
Chile's C4 is the only one of the three with a technical secretariat. External funding from the Inter-American Development Bank and the NDC Partnership expanded the C4 from one staff member to three. Members credited that expansion with the committee's capacity for substantive work. In its first months, the committee's members reviewed nine policy documents of more than 100 pages each, on top of their regular jobs. As one member put it, "without it, committee members are essentially on their own."
When the external funding ended, the secretariat returned to a single staff member, reducing the support available to the committee and exposing its reliance on temporary funding arrangements, restricting its capacity to respond to committee duties.
Mexico's C3 has no secretariat, no staff and no budget allocation that we could identify. Members described paying their own way to the rare in-person meetings. While their statute requires annual reporting, they have not been resourced or supported to carry out this function and lack a functioning communications apparatus.
Guatemala's SGCCC has deep scientific talent drawn from university members but a fragile legal footing. It is not set up as a legal entity, so it cannot receive grants directly —funds must be channeled through its member universities. At the time of our research, its five-year founding agreement had lapsed, leaving the system “legally in limbo,” according to one of its members.
All of these gaps can be addressed, though most would require action by policymakers to strengthen legal mandates and create secure adequate resources.
From Advice to Response
To make sure a council’s advice makes an impact, there needs to be a legal requirement for a government to consider and respond to it. In Mexico, Guatemala and Chile, governments are not explicitly required to publish a response to the advice received from climate councils. This can become important if collaboration and consultation is held up only by norms rather than rules — before Mexico’s current administration, the C3 was marginalized in the decision-making process and treated as an afterthought, according to stakeholders we interviewed who served on the C3 and in government during that time. Lacking an explicit mandate to gather input and publish a response, the C3 and its advice was easier to disregard.
Elsewhere, stronger mechanisms make councils difficult to ignore. For example, the United Kingdom government is legally bound to respond to the recommendations of the Climate Change Committee on carbon budgets. Research on a decade of parliamentary debate found that all major UK parties draw on the committee's analysis, often to hold government accountable and push for more ambitious policy. Similarly, Denmark's government must respond to the annual review of its Council on Climate Change.
Most climate advisory councils around the world have a watchdog role in their mandate: monitoring progress and holding governments accountable. None of these three councils is tasked with periodically assessing and reporting on climate policy progress to create visibility, credibility and accountability domestically or internationally. To ensure future leaders consider and respond to advice from qualified experts and scientists, policymakers should consider creating clear legal obligations for the government to seek and respond to their advisory councils’ input.
From the Capital to the Territories and Citizens
In the cases of Chile, Guatemala and Mexico, councils have generally expanded their activities beyond their formal mandates through their own initiative rather than through dedicated explicit legal powers or resources. For example, Chile's C4 built a research network of more than 500 experts and a community network of over 150 participants. It also held regional scientific dialogues outside Santiago.
The role that councils can play to best fill governance gaps in their countries may evolve over time. While originally created to synthesize climate science for policymakers, members of Guatemala's SGCCC have questioned how significantly the government considers their counsel. On the other hand, the SGCCC was lauded by government officials and stakeholders for its improvised role in leading a National Climate Change Congress that brings civil society from outside the capital into an agenda partly shaped by participants.
In Mexico, 12 states now have their own operational climate councils and there is mutual interest between them and the C3 to deepen the collaboration and exchange to better represent state-level climate priorities in national recommendations. Australia, which presides over the COP31 negotiations, offers a model: In 2025, it launched a network linking its federal and subnational climate councils.
There’s an opportunity for greater public and stakeholder visibility of the councils’ activities, recommendations and influence in all three countries. Chile's committee is only mostly known among government and specialist circles. A Mexican citizen would not be able to find any of C3’s recommendations, minutes or annual reports. This challenge is closely linked to a lack of staffing, budget and institutional capacity to communicate more consistently and in a more structured fashion with key climate governance actors beyond the Ministry of Environment — such as legislatures, subnational authorities, sector associations and Indigenous leaders.
How to Make Climate Councils Count
All three countries we examined in our working paper are facing opportune political moments to reinforce their councils’ abilities to support climate action. Chile's committee faces its first change of government since the framework law passed. Guatemala's founding agreement needs renewal. Mexico is amending its General Law on Climate Change, and officials say the C3's role is under discussion.
In these three countries’ cases, we find the following institutional conditions could elevate the ability of climate councils to strengthen policy and governance:
- A duty to respond. Governments should be required to formally answer council recommendations and make those responses public, as in the UK, Denmark or Canada. In Mexico, Guatemala and Chile, this would require new or amended legislation.
- A permanent, funded secretariat. Where domestic budgets fall short, international funders can backstop it in ways that protect the council’s independence.
- Earlier council involvement in policy processes with enhanced data access. Councils should be invited to engage while drafts are still being shaped, with minimum review periods for key instruments and full access to supporting data.
- Enhanced public and stakeholder visibility on the climate council’s role, operations and activities. Due primarily to a lack of resources and staff, the activities and impact of these councils are not well known beyond the agencies they advise, limiting their ability to generate broader support for science-based climate policy.
- Channels beyond the executive. Councils need to be empowered through mandates and resources to reach legislatures, subnational governments and the public.
These reforms also speak directly to what governments will be asked to demonstrate at COP31. Climate advisory councils represent a climate governance innovation that is proving its impact in strengthening credible domestic implementation of the NDCs across the globe. As the second Global Stocktake to assess collective progress kicks off, climate councils can play a role in facilitating inputs on the implementation of national climate actions. A well-equipped climate council draws on national, independent and scientific expertise from universities, think tanks and other sources across civil society to align climate policies to scientific advice that’s fit for country contexts. Councils need to have a clear mandate to advise on targets, scrutinize plans and track progress, helping improve policy credibility, ambition and accountability of implementation.
The direct quotes in this article come from interviews conducted as part of formal research. In keeping with WRI’s ethical standards for research involving human participants, interviewees were promised anonymity and are identified only by their affiliation.
Projects
Long-Term Climate Strategies
Part of Climate