Thirsting for Justice
Transparency and Poor People’s Struggle for Clean Water in Indonesia, Mongolia, and Thailand
Industrial facilities release upwards of 400 million tons of toxic pollutants into the world’s waters each year. Yet secrecy around the amount and type of chemicals that companies discharge is still the norm, especially in Asia. Contaminated water threatens the region’s poorest communities—those who still depend on local water sources for their lives and livelihoods. Without access to water pollution information, they can’t determine whether their water is safe to drink, fish or give to their animals. They can’t participate in decision-making, hold law-breaking polluters to account or lead local cleanup efforts.
Thirsting for Justice: Transparency and Poor People’s Struggle for Clean Water in Indonesia, Mongolia, and Thailand reveals that, like many Asian countries, the governments of Indonesia, Mongolia and Thailand are not effectively telling the public if the water they rely on for drinking, bathing, farming and fishing is polluted or dangerously toxic. The Access Initiative (TAI) report finds that, despite passing strong “right to know” laws, these governments are putting their poorest communities at risk by not providing the water pollution information that people need.
Working with TAI partners, the report authors performed a legal analysis to identify what pollution information governments must release to the public. They then reviewed state of environment reports, water quality monitoring portals and other public databases and documents to assess the availability of this information in practice. They also tracked 174 information requests that local community members submitted and spoke with close to 150 affected people to understand the barriers that they faced when accessing water pollution information. This analysis shows that, although governments have passed laws that protect citizens’ right to environmental information and mandate disclosure of this data, officials are failing to provide information that they are legally obligated to release.
Rapid economic growth in many developing countries has increased the amount of pollution entering the world’s waterways, with dire consequences for poor communities who rely on local water sources for their health and economic well-being.
The report explores the challenges that poor communities in Indonesia, Thailand and Mongolia face when they try to obtain water pollution information, and it evaluates the multiple laws and pathways that dictate the disclosure of pollution information in each country.
TAI’s findings reveal that the company-specific, local information that communities need is simply not available. Despite passing comprehensive laws that clearly require governments to disclose environmental data, countries are failing to effectively release pollution information. Poor implementation of these “right to know” laws and complicated disclosure mechanisms block people’s access to pollution information.
To address these challenges, the governments of Indonesia, Thailand and Mongolia can improve implementation of existing transparency laws and develop centralized systems to release information both online and in formats that are locally accessible offline.
Donors should support community efforts to obtain and use information, while civil society groups can help build communities’ capacity to participate in water governance decision-making forums.
Advancing Community-Driven Solutions for Clean Air and WaterLaunch PlatformLaunch Platform Visit Project
Ensuring that poor, vulnerable communities everywhere have the voice, power and information to protect their right to a safe, clean and healthy environment.Part of Equity
The Access Initiative (TAI)Launch PlatformLaunch Platform Visit Project
The Access Initiative (TAI) is a partnership network dedicated to ensuring that citizens have the right and ability to influence decisions about their natural resources.Part of Environmental Rights
Environmental RightsVisit Project
Protecting people and the planet by strengthening natural resource rights and ensuring that everyone, everywhere, has the information, voice and power to shape environmental decision-making.Part of Equity