Kyoto Goal: Cut emissions by 5 percent

Kyoto Goal: Cut Emissions by 5 Percent
Target Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reductions by 2012, Kyoto Protocol

Country Kyoto Target
(percent change from 1990 emissions)
Australia +8
Bulgaria -8
Canada -6
Croatia -5
Estonia -8
European Union -8
Hungary -6
Iceland +10
Japan -6
Latvia -8
Liechtenstein -8
Lithuania -8
Monaco -8
New Zealand 0
Norway +1
Poland -6
Romania -8
Russian Federation 0
Slovakia -8
Slovenia -8
Switzerland -8
Ukraine 0
United States -7

Source: United Nations (U.N.), Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, Article 3, Annex B (U.N., New York, 1997). Available online at: http://www.unfccc.de (January 18, 1998).

Emissions Reflect Economic Size

Fifteen Countries with the Highest Industrial Emissions of Carbon Dioxide
COUNTRY TOTAL CO2 EMISSIONS (000 metric tons)
South Africa 305,805
Poland, Rep 338,044
France 340,085
Mexico 357,834
Korea, Rep 373,592
Italy 409,983
Canada 435,749
Ukraine 438,211
United Kingdom 542,140
Germany 835,099
India 908,734
Japan 1,126,753
Russian Federation 1,818,011
China 3,192,484
United States 5,468,564

Source: Carbon Dioxide Information Analysis Center (CDIAC), Environmental Sciences Division, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, “1995 Estimates of CO2 Emissions from Fossil Fuel Burning and Cement Manufacturing Based on the United Nations Energy Statistics andthe U.S. Bureau of Mines Cement Manufacturing Data,” ORNL/CDIAD-25, NDP-030 (an accessible numerical database) (Oak Ridge, Tennessee, November 1997).

Another problematic area is that the treaty is ambiguous regarding the extent to which developing nations will participate in the effort to limit global emissions. The original 1992 climate treaty made it clear that, while the developed nations most responsible for the current buildup of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere should take the lead in combating climate change, developing nations also have a role to play in protecting the global climate [5]. (See Per Capita CO2 Emissions Are Small in Developing Countries and Developed Nations Have Altered the Atmosphere the Most.) However, the Kyoto Protocol does not set any binding limits on developing nation emissions, nor does it establish a mechanism or timetable for these countries to take on such limits voluntarily. On the other hand, the Protocol does establish a so-called Clean Development Mechanism, which allows developed countries to invest in projects in developing countries that reduce greenhouse gas emissions and receive credit for the reductions. The intent is to help developing nations minimize their emissions even as they develop their energy sectors and expand their economies [6].

References and notes

5. Ibid., p. 121.

6. Op. cit. 4, pp. 124-125.